Melencolia I
Melencolia I | |
---|---|
Artist | Albrecht Dürer |
Year | 1514 |
Type | engraving |
Dimensions | 24 cm × 18.8 cm (9.4 in × 7.4 in) |
Melencolia I is a large 1514 engraving by the German Renaissance artist Albrecht Dürer. Its central subject is an enigmatic and gloomy winged female figure thought to be a personification of melancholia – melancholy. Holding her head in her hand, she stares past the busy scene in front of her. The area is strewn with symbols and tools associated with craft and carpentry, including an hourglass, weighing scales, a hand plane, a claw hammer, and a saw. Other objects relate to alchemy, geometry or numerology. Behind the figure is a structure with an embedded magic square, and a ladder leading beyond the frame. The sky contains a rainbow, a comet or planet, and a bat-like creature bearing the text that has become the print's title.
Dürer's engraving is one of the most well-known extant
The art historian Erwin Panofsky, whose writing on the print has received the most attention, detailed its possible relation to Renaissance humanists' conception of melancholia. Summarizing its art-historical legacy, he wrote that "the influence of Dürer's Melencolia I—the first representation in which the concept of melancholy was transplanted from the plane of scientific and pseudo-scientific folklore to the level of art—extended all over the European continent and lasted for more than three centuries."[4]
Context
Melencolia I has been the subject of more scholarship than probably any other print. As the art historian
There is little documentation to provide insight into Dürer's intent.
Panofsky considered but rejected the suggestion that the "I" in the title might indicate that Dürer had planned three other engravings on the four temperaments.[16] He suggested instead that the "I" referred to the first of three types of melancholy defined by Cornelius Agrippa (see Interpretation). Others see the "I" as a reference to nigredo, the first stage of the alchemical process.[17]
Description
The winged, central figure is thought to be a personification of
A bat-like creature spreads its wings across the sky, revealing a banner printed with the words "Melencolia I". Beyond it is a rainbow and an object which is either Saturn or a comet. In the far distance is a landscape with small treed islands, suggesting flooding, and a sea. The rightmost portion of the background may show a large wave crashing over land. Panofsky believes that it is night, citing the "cast-shadow" of the hourglass on the building, with the moon lighting the scene and creating a
The print contains numerous
In contrast with
Interpretations
Dürer's friend and first biographer Joachim Camerarius wrote the earliest account of the engraving in 1541. Addressing its apparent symbolism, he said, "to show that such [afflicted] minds commonly grasp everything and how they are frequently carried away into absurdities, [Dürer] reared up in front of her a ladder into the clouds, while the ascent by means of rungs is ... impeded by a square block of stone."[35] Later, the 16th-century art historian Giorgio Vasari described Melencolia I as a technical achievement that "puts the whole world in awe".[36]
Most art historians view the print as an allegory, assuming that a unified theme can be found in the image if its constituent symbols are "unlocked" and brought into conceptual order. This sort of interpretation assumes that the print is a Vexierbild (a "puzzle image") or rebus whose ambiguities are resolvable.[37] Others see the ambiguity as intentional and unresolvable. Merback notes that ambiguities remain even after the interpretation of numerous individual symbols: the viewer does not know if it is daytime or twilight, where the figures are located, or the source of illumination.[22] The ladder leaning against the structure has no obvious beginning or end, and the structure overall has no obvious function. The bat may be flying from the scene, or is perhaps some sort of daemon related to the traditional conception of melancholia.
Certain relationships in humorism, astrology, and alchemy are important for understanding the interpretive history of the print. Since the ancient Greeks, the health and temperament of an individual were thought to be determined by the four humors: black bile (melancholic humor), yellow bile (choleric), phlegm (phlegmatic), and blood (sanguine). In astrology, each temperament was under the influence of a planet, Saturn in the case of melancholia. Each temperament was also associated with one of the four elements; melancholia was paired with Earth, and was considered "dry and cold" in alchemy. Melancholia was traditionally the least desirable of the four temperaments, making for a constitution that was, according to Panofsky, "awkward, miserly, spiteful, greedy, malicious, cowardly, faithless, irreverent and drowsy".[38]
In 1905,
Iconography
According to Panofsky, who wrote about the print three times between 1923 and 1964,
Other aspects of the print reflect the traditional symbolism of melancholy, such as the bat, emaciated dog, purse and keys. The figure wears a wreath of "wet" plants to counteract the dryness of melancholy, and she has the dark face and dishevelled appearance associated with the melancholic. The intensity of her gaze, however, suggests an intent to depart from traditional depictions of this temperament. The magic square is a talisman of Jupiter, an auspicious planet that fends off melancholy—different square sizes were associated with different planets, with the 4×4 square representing Jupiter.[43][44] Even the distant seascape, with small islands of flooded trees, relates to Saturn, the "lord of the sea", and his control of floods and tides.[45]
Panofsky believed that Dürer's understanding of melancholy was influenced by the writings of the German
Agrippa defined three types of melancholic genius in his
Autobiography runs through many of the interpretations of Melencolia I, including Panofsky's. Iván Fenyő considered the print a representation of an artist beset by a loss of confidence, saying: "shortly before [Dürer] drew Melancholy, he wrote: 'what is beautiful I do not know' ... Melancholy is a lyric confession, the self-conscious introspection of the Renaissance artist, unprecedented in northern art. Erwin Panofsky is right in considering this admirable plate the spiritual self-portrait of Dürer."[50]
Within the magic square of Melencolia § I, the combinations to be recognized are varied and surprising: «each corner group, formed by four squares (16, 3, 5, 10 - 2, 13, 11, 8 - 9, 6, 4, 15 – 7, 12, 14, 1), has the sum of 34. The same number is obtained by adding the digits of the central group (10, 11, 6, 7), but also those of the corner squares (16, 13, 4, 1). The same result is obtained by adding the digits on the horizontal, vertical, diagonal lines. We always get 34. In total, the number occurs sixteen times. Sixteen is the total number of enclosed squares. This is a property that also appears in Henricus Cornelius Agrippa von Nettesheim's Tabula Jovis, but which has gone unnoticed by many, perhaps because it does not appear in the list of its characteristics, drawn up by the author himself.[51] The characteristic of the sums of each zone is also shared in the analogous schemes of Mescupolo and Paracelsus.[52] Despite the similarity with these, the magic square of Melencolia § I does not seem chosen to follow a hermetic tradition. The unspoken exclusivity of this type of square may be the reason for the dedication to Jupiter (privileged among the gods and the greatest of the planets) and for Dürer's choice. In truth, its most reliable source is found in the description that Luca Pacioli proposes as a pleasant curiosity [«ligiadro solazo» (f. 122r)], attributing its origin to the greatest astronomers, "Ptolomeo al humasar ali, al fragano, Geber and to all the others ". These "have dedicated to Jupiter [planet «Giove»][53] the figure made up of 4 squares on each side, with the numbers arranged in such a way as to obtain 34 for each direction, that is 16, 3, 2, 13 and in the following line 5, 10, 11, 8, therefore in the third line 9 [etc.] as seen in the margin."[54]» [55] Since this indicated scheme does not appear in the manuscript, it has been completed with blue digits (see image). The magic square of Melencolia § I represents a jovial exercise (lat. iovialis, from Iovis) to counter the influences of melancholy. In the lower center, the union of the numbers 15 and 14 indicates a very sad year.[56]
Beyond allegory
In 1991, Peter-Klaus Schuster published Melencolia I: Dürers Denkbild,[57] an exhaustive history of the print's interpretation in two volumes. His analysis, that Melencolia I is an "elaborately wrought allegory of virtue ... structured through an almost diagrammatic opposition of virtue and fortune", arrived as allegorical readings were coming into question.[58] In the 1980s, scholars began to focus on the inherent contradictions of the print, finding a mismatch between "intention and result" in the interpretive effort it seemingly required.[59] Martin Büchsel, in contrast to Panofsky, found the print a negation of Ficino's humanistic conception of melancholia.[59] The chaos of the print lends itself to modern interpretations that find it a comment on the limitations of reason, the mind and senses, and philosophical optimism.[59] For example, Dürer perhaps made the image impenetrable in order to simulate the experience of melancholia in the viewer.
In 2004, Patrick Doorly argued that Dürer was more concerned with beauty than melancholy. Doorly found textual support for elements of Melencolia I in Plato's Hippias Major, a dialog about what constitutes the beautiful, and other works that Dürer would have read in conjunction with his belief that beauty and geometry, or measurement, were related. (Dürer wrote a treatise on human proportions, one of his last major accomplishments.) Dürer was exposed to a variety of literature that may have influenced the engraving by his friend and collaborator, the humanist Willibald Pirckheimer, who also translated from Greek. In Plato's dialog, Socrates and Hippias consider numerous definitions of the beautiful. They ask if that which is pleasant to sight and hearing is the beautiful, which Dürer symbolizes by the intense gaze of the figure, and the bell, respectively. The dialog then examines the notion that the "useful" is the beautiful, and Dürer wrote in his notes, "Usefulness is a part of beauty. Therefore what is useless in a man, is not beautiful." Doorly interprets the many useful tools in the engraving as symbolizing this idea; even the dog is a "useful" hunting hound. At one point the dialog refers to a millstone, an unusually specific object to appear in both sources by coincidence. Further, Dürer may have seen the perfect dodecahedron as representative of the beautiful (the "quintessence"), based on his understanding of Platonic solids. The "botched" polyhedron in the engraving therefore symbolises a failure to understand beauty, and the figure, standing in for the artist, is in a gloom as a result.[19]
In Perfection's Therapy (2017), Merback argues that Dürer intended Melencolia I as a therapeutic image. He reviews the history of images of spiritual consolation in the Middle Ages and the Renaissance, and highlights how Dürer expressed his ethical and spiritual commitment to friends and community through his art. He writes, the "thematic of a virtue-building inner reflection, understood as an ethical-therapeutic imperative for the new type of pious intellectual envisioned by humanism, certainly underlies the conception of Melencolia".[60] Dürer's friendships with humanists enlivened and advanced his artistic projects, building in him the "self-conception of an artist with the power to heal".[61] Treatments for melancholia in ancient times and in the Renaissance occasionally recognized the value of "reasoned reflection and exhortation"[62] and emphasized the regulation of melancholia rather than its elimination "so that it can better fulfill its God-given role as a material aid for the enhancement of human genius".[63] The ambiguity of Melencolia I in this view "offers a moderate mental workout that calms rather than excites the passions, a stimulation of the soul's higher powers, an evacuative that dispels the vapors beclouding the mind... This, in a word, is a form of katharsis—not in the medical or religious sense of a 'purgation' of negative emotions, but a 'clarification' of the passions with both ethical and spiritual consequences".[64]
Legacy
Artists from the sixteenth century used Melencolia I as a source, either in single images personifying melancholia or in the older type in which all four temperaments appear.
The print attracted nineteenth-century Romantic artists; self-portrait drawings by Henry Fuseli and Caspar David Friedrich show their interest in capturing the mood of the Melencolia figure, as does Friedrich's The Woman with the Spider's Web.[68]
The Renaissance historian
The Passion façade of the Sagrada Família contains a magic square based on[70] the magic square in Melencolia I. The square is rotated and one number in each row and column is reduced by one so the rows and columns add up to 33 instead of the standard 34 for a 4x4 magic square.
-
Lucas Cranach the Elder's 1532 painting Melancholia (Colmar version)
-
Hans Sebald Beham's Melancholia (1539)
-
Jost Amman's Melancholia (1589)
-
Jan Wierix's 1602 copy
-
The Woman with the Spider's Web or Melancholy. Woodcut after an 1803 drawing by Caspar David Friedrich[68]
-
Friedrich's pre-1840 self-portrait[68]
-
Semiramis and Ara (1899) by Vardges Sureniants
References
- ^ The engraving's common second state. For the first state, see the version from the collection of Sir Thomas Barlow, which differs in the number nine in the magic square.
- ^ For example, Bartrum et al., 188
- ^ Sander, 262
- ^ Quoted in Tsu-Chung Su (March 2007). "An Uncanny Melancholia: The Frame, the Gaze, and the Representation of Melancholia in Albrecht Dürer's Engraving Melencolia I". Concentric: Literary and Cultural Studies. 33 (1): 145–175.
- ^ Dodgson, Campbell (1926). Albrecht Dürer. London: Medici Society. p. 94. The quote is commonly cited in later literature (e.g., Doorly).
- ^ JSTOR 42617907.
- ^ a b Panofsky, 156
- ^ "Albrecht Dürer, Knight, Death and the Devil, a copperplate engraving". British Museum. Archived from the original on 8 November 2014. Retrieved 12 June 2010.
- ^ ISBN 9780226449999.
- ISBN 9780870994661.
- ^ a b c Fenyő, Iván (1956). Albrecht Dürer. Budapest: Corvina. p. 51.
- ^ Merback, 36
- ^ a b Panofsky, 170
- ^ Merback, 177ff.
- ^ Merback, 15. The work is Ein Speis der Malerknaben, "Nourishment for Young Painters" (c. 1512).
- ^ Panofsky, 168
- ^ Pinkus, Karen (2010). Alchemical Mercury: A Theory of Ambivalence. Stanford University Press. p. 143.
- ^ Merback, 56–58
- ^ JSTOR 3177417.
- ^ JSTOR 1483470.
- ^ Klibansky, Panofsky & Saxl, 325
- ^ a b Merback, 38
- ^ e.g., Klibansky, Panofsky & Saxl, 321
- ^ Klibansky, Panofsky & Saxl, 314, fn. 105
- ISBN 9781317179252.
- ^ McNeely, M. (2008). "Dürer's 'Melancholia I': A 16th Century Tribute to Mathematics". Pi in the Sky (11): 10–11.
- ^ Weisstein, Eric W. "Dürer's Magic Square". Wolfram MathWorld. Retrieved 26 April 2018.
- ^ Some sources give May 16.
- ^ Merback, 59
- ^ Weisstein, Eric W. "Dürer's Solid". Wolfram MathWorld. Retrieved 21 April 2008.
- ^ a b Merback, 61
- .
- ^ a b Merback, 54–55
- S2CID 195006163.
- ^ Quoted in Merback, 37
- ^ Merback (translating Vasari), 10. See Le vite de' più eccellenti pittori, scultori e architetti, Volume 9
- ^ Merback, 37–38, 48
- ^ Panofsky, 157–58
- ^ Summarized in Merback, 39
- ^ a b Panofsky, 161
- ^ Panofsky wrote, with Fritz Saxl, Dürers "Melencolia I": eine quellen- und typengeschichtliche Untersuchung in 1923, followed by a Dürer monograph in 1943 which devotes a section to the print, and, with two co-authors, Saturn and Melancholy in 1964.
- ^ Klibansky, Panofsky & Saxl, 315
- ISBN 0-691-07041-5.
- ^ Klibansky, Panofsky & Saxl, 271, 325
- ^ Klibansky, Panofsky & Saxl, 324
- ISBN 9780816645398.
- ^ As Agrippa's study was published in 1531, Panofsky assumes that Dürer had access to a manuscript. This assumption has been challenged, such as by Hoffman, summarized in Merback, 43.
- ^ Klibansky, Panofsky & Saxl, 345
- ^ Klibansky, Panofsky & Saxl, 320
- ^ Fenyő, Iván (1956). Albrecht Dürer. Budapest: Corvina. p. 52.
- ^ Henricus Cornelius Agrippa von Nettesheim, De occulta philosophia, Liber secundus, Caput XXII, p. CXLIX, ed. 1533, Biblioteca Trivulziana, Milano.
- ^ Reproduced in: Maurizio Calvesi, La melanconia di Albrecht Dürer, p. 127, Einaudi, Torino1993.
- ^ The "square of Jupiter presents the same arrangement that is seen in Dürer's Melencolia I." (R. Klibansky, E. Panofsky, F. Saxl, Saturno e la Melanconia [Saturn and Melancholy], Pare quarta, II, 2, b) I, p. 306, Einaudi, Torino 1983).
- ^ «a Giove hanno dicata la figura de .4. casi per facia con numeri situati ch’ per ogni verso ut supra fanno .34. cioe .16.3.2.13. elasse’quente .5.10.11.8. el .3°.9. [etc.] co’mo vedi in margine» (Luca Pacioli, De viribus quantitatis [composed between 1496 and 1509], Parte prima, Delle forze numerali cioe de Arithmetica, Cap. LXXII, [f. 118r, 118v], Code 250 of the University Library of Bologna).
- ^ Ezio Fiorillo, Melencolia § II, pp. 79-81, All’insegna del Matamoros, Algua (Bergamo) 2016. In Italian language. Digital edition. ISBN 978-88-907489-6-7.
- ^ "The drawing of the mother preserved in Berlin (charcoal, L. 40) is from 1514, the year of Melelcolia. It is also the year of the woman's death." (Heinrich Wölfflin, Albrecht Dürer [Die Kunst Albrecht Dürers], X, 4, p. 238, Salerno Editrice, Roma 1987).
- ^ Schuster, Peter-Klaus (1991). Melencolia I: Dürers Denkbild (in German). Berlin: Gebr. Mann Verlag.
- ^ Merback, 47–48 (Merback's summary of Schuster quoted)
- ^ a b c Merback, 49
- ^ Merback, 199
- ^ Merback, 227
- ^ Merback, 147
- ^ Merback, 149
- ^ Merback, 149–150
- ^ Merback, 131–133
- ^ ISBN 9781134524419.
- ^ Klibansky, Panofsky & Saxl, 376–389
- ^ a b c Bartrum et al., 296–298
- ^ Bartrum et al., 294
- ^ "The magic square on the Passion façade: keys to understanding it". Blog Sagrada Família. 7 February 2018. Retrieved 7 December 2018.
Works cited
- Bartrum, Giulia; Koerner, Joseph Leo; Kuhlemann, Ute (2002). Albrecht Dürer and His Legacy: The Graphic Work of a Renaissance Artist. British Museum. ISBN 978-0-7141-2633-3.
- Klibansky, Raymond; Panofsky, Erwin; Saxl, Fritz (1979) [1964]. Saturn and Melancholy: Studies in the History of Natural Philosophy, Religion and Art. Nendeln/Liechtenstein: Kraus Reprint.
- Merback, Mitchell B. (2017). Perfection's Therapy: An Essay on Albrecht Dürer's Melencolia I. New York: Zone Books. ISBN 978-1-9421-3000-0.
- Panofsky, Erwin (1955) [1943]. The Life and Art of Albrecht Dürer (PDF) (4th ed.). Princeton: Princeton University Press.
- Sander, Jochen (2013). Dürer: His Art in Context. Frankfurt: Städel Museum & Prestelt. ISBN 978-3-7913-5317-3.