The Ingenuity Gap
LC Class HM846 .H663 2000 | | |
Website | homerdixon.com |
---|
The Ingenuity Gap is a non-fiction book by Canadian academic
After
Background
Author Thomas Homer-Dixon was a 44-year-old academic and director at the
Content
Homer-Dixon begins by presenting his personal and academic background that led to the drafting of this book. He establishes that the nature of problems are becoming overly burdensome, including providing resources for exponentially growing populations, managing international environmental impacts, and creating a secure global economic market. Modern problems often contain numerous factors that interact to create hidden
As older problems are solved, more complexities are being introduced, like adding additional parts to an engine. Interaction of these new parts, or niches, create emergent properties, like time-saving office devices (e.g. email, mobile computers, etc.) make communication more efficient but also expand the network of contacts and increase the amount of time spent on such duties. Homer-Dixon relates this to complexity theory explaining that as new niches are filled there is a synergistic burst of simplicity. However, this can also lead to less control or freedom as emergent properties are created, like a new government program leading to a sprawling bureaucracy. Information theory is touched upon relating the amount of information required to describe a system and the degree of that system's complexity. Chaos theory is used to describe how small changes can lead to widely varying results and path dependence.
Homer-Dixon explains how his theory was influenced by
Style
The Ingenuity Gap is a popular science book.[10] Homer-Dixon takes an inter-disciplinary approach connecting political science with sociology, economics, history, biology, and ecology.[11][12][13] The narrative is structured as a travelogue as the author travels to meet experts and construct his theory.[14] His observations along the way illustrate the concepts he is explaining and supplement interviews and research. Collecting pieces of his theory from each of his interviews and destinations appears as a recurring metaphor.[15] He includes anecdotes and social commentary.[3]
Publication and reception
The book was published in September 2000 as a hardcover, and Homer-Dixon shortly after began a 10-city tour across Canada with stops in Toronto, Ottawa, Kingston, Hamilton, London, Winnipeg, Calgary, Edmonton, Vancouver, and Victoria, amongst several other smaller venues.
The book's scholarship was very well received by critics.[21][22][23] The research behind the book was called impressive for its breadth, and its presentation was said to be straightforward and thought-provoking.[12][21][23][24][25] Critics called Homer-Dixon's writing clear, accessible, and engaging.[24][26] In his review in the Quill & Quire, Mark Shainblum wrote "[d]espite the book's serious import and prodigious endnotes, The Ingenuity Gap is a surprisingly engaging and even exciting read. Homer-Dixon spins parables masterfully, using comprehensible examples to represent the almost incomprehensible complexity of our social system."[26] The Library Journal highly recommended it for academic and general public libraries.[25] Several critics were disappointed by the lack of recommendations to address the problems he raises. The reviewers for Books in Canada, The Canadian Geographer, and the National Post found Homer-Dixon's writing self-indulgent because it overly details his travels and experiences, and because of his overly authoritative tone that compliments people that agree with him and shows little consideration of differing perspectives.[27][28][29]
References
- ^ a b c Bethune, Brian (October 30, 2000). "Future complex". Maclean's. 113 (44): 56.
- ^ Stevens, William K. (April 5, 1994). "Feeding a Booming Population Without Destroying the Planet". The New York Times. p. C1. Retrieved 2009-01-31.
- ^ a b Zacharias, Yvonne; Douglas Todd (June 14, 2002). "Wake-up call to a complacent world". Vancouver Sun. p. A1.
- ^ a b Laver, Ross (September 5, 1994). "Looking for trouble: Tad Homer-Dixon's prophesies for a crowded planet have created a stir in Washington". Maclean's. 107: 18–22.
- ^ Kaplan, Robert. "The Coming Anarchy - The Atlantic (February 1994)". www.theatlantic.com. p. 3. Retrieved 2009-01-31.
- ^ Kapaln, Robert. "The Coming Anarchy - The Atlantic (February 1994)". www.theatlantic.com. p. 4. Retrieved 2009-01-31.
- ^ a b c Smith, Stephen (August 2000). "Is the world too complex for its own good?". Quill & Quire. 66 (8): 9.
- ^ Curtis, Jenefer (October 21, 2000). "Stop. Look. Think". The Globe and Mail. p. D8.
- ^ Toller, Carol (December 1996). "In the Works". Quill & Quire. 62 (12): 13.
- ^ Goldblatt, David (December 7, 2000). "This gap seems more like the Grand Canyon". The Independent. London. p. 5.
- ^ Ross, Oakland (October 9, 2000). "Don't worry, be happy". Toronto Star. p. EN01.
- ^ a b Christian, Dorothy (November–December 2000). "The Ingenuity Gap (Book Review)". Natural Life (76): 25.
- ^ "The Ingenuity Gap (Book Review)". Publishers Weekly. 247 (35): 64. August 28, 2000.
- ^ Struzik, Ed (December 31, 2000). "Doomsday travelogue". Edmonton Journal. p. E13.
- ISSN 0049-3929.
- Report on Business Magazine. 17 (4): 115–118.
- ^ "Top selling fiction and non-fiction titles". Maclean's. November 27, 2000.. Note: The book debuted at #4 on November 6 and was listed at #1 in the November 13, November 20, and November 27 issues. It was #6 on December 4, #10 on December 10, and #9 on December 18.
- ^ Maney, Kevin (April 25, 2001). "Nanotechnology has us in its sights". USA Today. p. 6B.
- ^ "Thomas Homer-Dixon is a familiar enough name around the halls of the University of Toronto these days". Toronto Star. April 6, 2002.
- ISSN 0049-4194.
- ^ a b Cimino, John; Ted Buswick; Harvey Seifter (2005). "The Ingenuity Gap: Facing the Economic, Environmental, and Other Challenges of an Increasingly Complex and Unpredictable World". Journal of Business Strategy. 26 (5): 73–74.
- ^ Kates, Robert W. (July–August 2002). "The Ingenuity Gap (Book)". Environment. 44 (6): 42.
- ^ a b Quinn, Gavin (October 1, 2000). "Adult Books: Nonfiction". Booklist. 97 (3): 294.
- ^ a b Hughes, Thomas P. (November 19, 2000). "Things Fall Apart". The Washington Post. p. 4.
- ^ a b Wood, Suzanne W. (October 1, 2000). "The Ingenuity Gap (Book Review)". Library Journal. 125 (16): 130.
- ^ a b Shainblum, Mark (October 2000). "The Ingenuity Gap (Book Review)". Quill & Quire. 66 (10): 34.
- ISSN 0045-2564.
- ^ Lemon, Jim (Spring 2003). "The Ingenuity Gap". The Canadian Geographer. 47 (1): 90.
- ^ Watson, William (October 21, 2000). "Headed for the future in an out-of-control DC-10". National Post.
- General references
- Gleditsch, Nils Petter; ISSN 0022-197X.
- Torrey, Barbara (Spring 2001). "Worrying Efficiently". Issues in Science & Technology. 17 (3): 87.
External links
- Official website
- "The Coming Anarchy" By Robert Kaplan, The Atlantic Monthly February 1994